You Don’t Need a Big Fish to Make a Great Fly-Fishing Story

Written by: Phil Monahan

I don’t recall many fish from this trip with my brother years ago, but I tell people about it all the time.
Photo by Tim Wade

We spend a lot of time posting fly-fishing success stories, the ones that end with a fish in the net and smiles all around. But those aren’t necessarily the best kinds of fishing tales, as I learned one day during my time as a guide in the Bristol Bay region of Alaska.

Two septuagenarian judges were the best pair of friends that I ever had the pleasure of fishing with. Bill and Hal been pals for almost 50 years, and they joked, reminisced, and bickered lightheartedly all through a slow, cool morning on the Copper River. In the afternoon, the trout in one long run started feeding on stonefly nymphs, and Bill was catching huge rainbows one after the other, while Hal—fishing exactly the same fly and indicator rig—couldn’t buy a fish. As you might imagine, Bill was enjoying himself, although it was hard to tell what was giving him more pleasure, the gorgeous trout he was landing or his buddy’s frustration.

But by the end of the day, Bill was desperate for Hal to catch a fish, and Hal was resigned to the fact that the angling gods had chosen to forsake him. Both were in stitches as they tried everything they could think of to give Hal an advantage—switching casting positions, trading rods, even trading hats and vests—but nothing could change their respective luck. I was dumbfounded by how the day had turned out, and I had no explanation for why only one of them had been catching fish.

Here’s the best part: When we got back to the lodge, there was neither boasting nor complaining about who caught trout and who didn’t; instead their “fish story” focused on this shared experience of bizarre and unexplainable luck. The story they took away from the day wasn’t about a particular trout or the number of trout Hal landed, but it was instead about their shared experience on the water.

What are your best fishing stories that aren’t about fish?

3 thoughts on “You Don’t Need a Big Fish to Make a Great Fly-Fishing Story

  1. Sharp Hook

    Nothing like fishing with friends, particularly old friends. I think you got Hal and Bill mixed up between the second and third paragraphs but the message still comes through.

  2. good stories

    Phil your photo caption leaves me really wanting to hear about the story of fishing with your brother you tell all the time , please share!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *